I was a fan of Grandma's Peanut Butter Cookies. Long ago they contained small chips of peanuts in them. Today, they taste the same but lack the peanuts. I've never had Nutter Butters. I'll have to try them.
Craving is the key word. I can go a year or two without even thinking of peanut butter cookies. Once they are on my mind, I have to have them.
My mother was a baker. We had cookies often. Chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, cinnamon apple, and peanut butter were in the nearly weekly rotation. Not to mention her pies, cakes, brownies, and bread to die for. My all time favorite was her banana pudding. Everything she made was from scratch and she had the talent and old school recipes.